Understanding Life in a Changing Planet

20+2 Years of Egenis, the Centre for the Study of the Life Sciences

Recordings uploaded and linked to talks for each day.

Conference reviews

Egenis conference 2024 review by Elis Jones (Konrad Lorenz Institute)

Programme

Marking the 20th anniversary of Egenis, this three-day event featured an exciting line-up of distinguished international guest speakers, alumni, and current members of Egenis. Speakers explored some of the key ideas developed at Egenis and their wider impact, as well as looking ahead to the main opportunities and challenges for the interdisciplinary studies of the life sciences in our changing planet. The event also honoured the achievements of Professor John Dupré, co-founder of Egenis and one of the world’s leading philosophers of biology.

The third day of the event featured each of Egenis’ research strands: Biology and Environment, Health and Biomedical Research, Mind, Body and Culture, and Data, Knowledge and Artificial Intelligence.

Speakers included: 

Rachel Ankeny, Nancy Cartwright, Hasok Chang, Ford Doolittle, Jim Griesemer, Paul Griffiths, Scott Gilbert, Adrian Haddock, Jonathan Kaplan, Katie Kendig, Philip Kitcher, Tim Lewens, Alan Love, Thomas Pradeu.

Egenis conference 2024 - Programme and abstracts final

A day exploring the major philosophical themes of Professor Dupré’s distinguished career, and their significance for contemporary and future interdisciplinary studies of the life sciences.

Welcome and Introduction  

John Dupré: Philosophy as Iconoclasm

Hasok Chang (University of Cambridge)

Economics and the Big Wide World Outside

Nancy Cartwright (Durham University)

Free Will Meets Human Behavior Genetics 

Jonathan M Kaplan (Oregan State University)

The Disorder of Processes: The Case of Human Nature

Tim Lewens (University of Cambridge)

“And the wine is bottled poetry”: Dupré on Reductionism and the Mental

Adrian Haddock (Universität Leipzig)

Soil and what to make of it?

Catherine Kendig (Michigan State University)

Thou hast taught me, Silent River, Many a lesson, deep and long

Scott Gilbert (Swarthmore College)

The Mighty Worlds We Half Create

Public Lecture

Philip Kitcher (Columbia University)

 

In celebration of Egenis’ twenty-year history friends and alumni explore some of the important impacts and ideas the centre has helped create, finishing with a poster session showcasing current work in the history, philosophy, and social studies of biology.

 

Welcome and Introduction

Sabina Leonelli

Sex as Process

Paul Griffiths (University of Sydney)

Darwinizing Gaia

Ford Doolittle (Dalhousie University)

Roundtable on Prospects for Interdisciplinary Studies of Life Sciences

Making Classes

Staffan Müller-Wille (University of Cambridge)

Navigating the Challenges of Interdisciplinarity: Some Personal Lessons

Dan Nicholson (George Mason University)

From studies of to studies with

Jane Calvert (University of Edinburgh)

Promiscuous mutualisms: The contribution of philosophers, especially John Dupré, to the scientific understanding of symbiosis

Thomas Pradeu (Boudeaux University)

Case reports in times of pandemic: Evolving entities, evolving knowledge

Rachel Ankeny (Wageningen University)

Philosophy of Biology in an Interdisciplinary Key

Alan C Love (University of Minnesota)

Entangled Banks of the River Reproduction: Thoughts on Thickety Nature, Science and Philosophy

Jim Griesemer (UC Davis)

Concluding talk

John Dupré

 

Current members of Egenis, as well as special guests, discuss major emerging topics in the social studies and philosophy of the life sciences. The discussion is organised along the four main strands of Egenis research activities.

Introduction & Opening 

Adam Toon 

Panel 1:

Biology and Environment theme

Environments across scales, values and contexts

The notion of an ‘environment’ is woven through scientific investigations, government policies and public imaginaries in a bewildering variety of ways. This panel and discussion brings together a diverse set of perspectives on what environments are, and why they matter, towards mapping similarities, differences and potential points of disagreement and tension. The session begins with a panel discussion. 5 panelists, who all interact with environments in different ways, from large-scale modelling, to public-facing heritage, to sociological and philosophical, will discuss how notions of environments play into their work. Several discussants from Egenis will then both pose questions and bring their own perspectives on the nature of the environment. Finally, the co-leads of the Biology & Environment strand will close with their own thoughts.

Panel: Melanie Smallman (UCL, Dept of Science and Technology Studies), Rose Trappes (Exeter, Egenis), Sam Scriven (Jurassic Coast Trust), Arwen Nicholson (Exeter, Physics & Astronomy), Andy Flack, (University of Bristol, Department of History)

Discussants: Astrid Schrader (Exeter, Egenis), Hugh Williamson (Exeter, Egenis/Business School), Oli Moore (Exeter, Egenis/CRPR)

Commentators: Adrian Currie (Exeter) and Angela Cassidy (Exeter)

Coffee break

Panel 2:

Data, Knowledge, and AI theme

Automation in Biological Research: Niccolò Tempini (Exeter), Celso Neto (Exeter), James Wakefield (Exeter), Sara Green 

Commentators: Stephan Güttinger (Exeter) and Sabina Leonelli (Exeter)

Lunch

Panel 3:

Health and Biomedical Research theme

Stigma emergence: A new theory of stigma change over time: Hannah Farrimond (Exeter)

Psychiatric fictionalism, diagnosis and epistemic injustice: Sam Wilkinson (Exeter)

The dynamic lifecycles of psychiatric categories: Ginny Russell (Exeter)

Commentator: Havi Carel (Bristol)

Coffee break

Panel 4:

Mind and Culture theme

(no recording)

Boundaries of the mind, boundaries of the discipline

In recent years, “4E approaches” have challenged the idea that to understand minds, we can focus exclusively on heads. These approaches instead defend a relational approach, one that sees minds as embodied, embedded, enacted, and maybe even extended beyond bodily boundaries and into the surrounding environment. Members of the “Mind and Culture” strand at Egenis have been at the forefront of this boundary-pushing work. They have applied 4E frameworks to diverse topics like emotions, perception and action, psychiatric disorder and classification, addiction, epistemology, modelling and scientific practice, technology and online sociality, religious cognition, artistic creativity, and musical experience. The influence of 4E frameworks continues to expand in philosophy, cognitive science, and beyond. This panel brings together leading scholars to discuss both their current work and future trends in 4E-inspired research.

Giovanna Colombetti (Exeter), Tom Roberts (Exeter), Becky Millar (Cardiff) 

Commentators: Paul Griffiths (Sydney), Lee Hogarth (Exeter)

 

Closing Discussion

 Sabina Leonelli, Adam Toon

End

Associated activity

Exeter Science and Technology Studies (STS) Network

Egenis has a strong tradition of STS scholarship in conversation with philosophy and history of the life sciences across multiple generations. This extends beyond our home department of SPSPA and in recent years STS has been flourishing at Exeter across many more disciplines, and concerns beyond the life sciences. In response, this lively community has recently started coming together for monthly brownbag lunch sessions

Organising committee

  • Sabina Leonelli
  • Adrian Currie
  • Chee Wong
  • John Dupré
  • Adam Toon
  • Stephan Güttinger
  • Celso Neto